Every subway system runs on two rulebooks. One is posted in the car; the other is enforced by sighs. We asked riders and crews in six markets to name the behaviours that actually move a train's effective capacity — and the answers were unnervingly consistent.
Doorway denial has stages
The crowd at the door refuses to move inward, bargaining ('I'm getting off soon'), then accepting its fate as the next boarding wave breaks around it. The single highest-leverage etiquette act on any line is walking to the centre of the car before checking your phone. It adds nothing to your trip and takes nothing off anyone else's.
The empty-seat lie
A bag on the adjacent seat costs the network roughly nothing per trip and a lot per million trips. The rule crews live by is visual: seats that look empty get used by people who need them; bags make a seat invisible to a pregnant rider or an elderly one during the exact second they are deciding whether to stand.
Sound, smell, and the sideways lean
Bleed from earbuds is the noise complaint that cannot be filed. Loud calls belong to the vestibule. Strong food belongs to the platform. And the sideways lean into a neighbour's shoulder while 'accidentally' asleep is the one etiquette violation crews agree should be criminalised, mildly, with eye contact.

Etiquette is not politeness — it is crowd engineering with manners. Every norm that survives on a real system reduces one measurable friction: door time, aisle blockage, shoulder contact, noise load. Keep the car flowing and you have done unpaid work for your whole line today.